Vance woos Jewish Republicans without criticizing Carlson

Vice President JD Vance on Tuesday sought to woo Jewish Republicans at a private Manhattan fundraiser, but his refusal to criticize Tucker Carlson—one of the right’s most influential voices—left some donors cold.

The event, hosted by a major Republican donor, was part of Vance’s push to solidify support among Jewish voters who have traditionally backed Democrats but are increasingly open to shifting toward the GOP. Vance, who has described himself as pro-Israel and has positioned himself as a bridge between the party’s Trump-aligned base and more traditional conservatives, faced questions about Carlson’s recent comments about Jewish Americans. The conservative commentator has been accused of trafficking in antisemitic tropes, including his suggestion that Jewish elites prioritize Israel over American interests. Vance declined to directly denounce Carlson, instead pivoting to his broader foreign policy stance, which includes strong support for Israel.

The fundraiser took place as Vance and other Trump allies work to reshape the party’s coalition ahead of the 2024 election. Jewish Republicans are a small but politically engaged voting bloc, and their support could be crucial in battleground states like Florida, Pennsylvania, and Michigan. Polls show growing skepticism among Jewish voters toward the Democratic Party, particularly on issues like Israel and rising antisemitism. However, Vance’s reluctance to fully distance himself from Carlson—a figure who has become a litmus test for the Trump-aligned right—risks alienating donors who see Carlson’s rhetoric as a bridge too far.

Vance’s team insists his approach is strategic, arguing that he can win over Jewish voters without alienating the party’s populist wing. But the episode underscores the tensions within the GOP as it tries to broaden its appeal while maintaining the loyalty of its core base. For now, the fundraiser’s mixed reception signals that Vance’s courtship of Jewish Republicans will be a slow burn—one that may require more than just pro-Israel talking points to win over a community deeply wary of the right’s most provocative voices. The next test could come in the coming weeks, as Vance prepares to address larger conservative audiences where Carlson’s influence looms large.